A More Accurate Historical Thanksgiving -What Are You Celebrating?

Posted By Jamie K Oxendine July 19th, 2011 Last Updated on: October 31st, 2020

Like most of our history, it comes from miss-history and the fact that most people think of the Pilgrims as these “incredibly righteous people” that invited the “savage Indians” to their first Thanksgiving so that the “savages” would not starve.  This is incorrect history and information.

Here is a more accurate historical Thanksgiving account.

Thanksgiving…oh that wonderful holiday in which we should give thanks.

Something we should do every day.

Where did this National holiday come from?

Well, it is not what you think and definitely not what you were taught in school. 

Many scholars give credit to the Americans, but many cultures and countries had “national days of giving thanks” long before the United States established such a day.

Thanksgiving Dinner

With that being the case, why do we think of the Pilgrims and Plymouth, Massachusetts for the national holiday of Thanksgiving?

What is the real history behind Thanksgiving?

Long before any Europeans came to the New World, Native Americans had many feasts and celebrations of thanks.

Although the Pilgrims were searching for some religious freedom from the British Crown, they were really nothing more than English Colonists.  They came for many other reasons also but regardless of what those reasons may have been, they were still loyal subjects to the British Crown.

In 1620 an English ship called the Mayflower set sail for the Americas. The ship was charted by a religious sect known as the Puritans. They were headed for what was called the Virginias.

Unfortunately, the Puritans ran out of beer and needed to make land as quickly as possible. Beer was used more often than water on the high seas since water on a ship could not be kept drinking safe. Thus they landed in December of 1620 on the shores of what is now Massachusetts.

They did not establish a settlement right away as often thought and taught in schools.  They were not able to settle at the original landing.

These so called Pilgrims were not the first Europeans to the shores of the New England coast. In 1605 a British expedition led by Captain George Weymouth had landed on this particular coastline. When they left in 1614 they took 24 Natives as slaves and left smallpox, syphilis, and gonorrhea in their wake.

One of the Natives taken back to Europe was named Tisquantum (called Squanto by the white man).

The 102 Puritans landed and built their colony called The Plymouth Plantation on the ruins of the Native village of Pawtuxet.  Pawtuxet had been destroyed by the Weymouth expedition. The Puritans survived by stealing the food stores of neighboring Native Summer Villages as well as eating corn that was still growing wild from abandoned cornfields near the ruined village.

Strangely enough, Tisquantum, who had survived his trips to Europe, happened to come upon these Puritans while hunting with another Native named Samoset.  They observed the newcomers and finally one day Tisquantum send Samoset over to greet the Puritans with the word “Welcome.”

Tisquantum soon joined and the Puritans were surprised to find two “savages” that spoke their language. The Puritans were terrible at survival, but with the help of Tisquantum they were able to harvest some late corn and learned to catch some game. Tisquantum also helped the colonists negotiate a treaty with the Wampanoag People near by who were led by Massasoit.

Still many of the Puritans quickly succumbed to pneumonia and consumption. It was a hard winter and some 46 of the original 102 Mayflower people died.

What really happened in 1621?

The next year, 1621, with the help of the Wampanoag People, the Puritans learned how to live and make a bountiful harvest. In celebration of their good fall harvest, the colony’s governor, William Bradford, declared a three-day feast after the harvest.

The Natives that attended this feast were not even invited.

The Puritans had only invited Massasoit the Wampanoag leader. It was Massasoit that brought the other 90 or more of his Native brothers and sisters that saved the colony to the chagrin of the rather rude and indignant Puritans. The Natives also provided most of the food.

There were no prayers of thanksgiving of any kind and the Natives were not invited back ever again for any other such events.

The following years the Puritans became pre-occupied with themselves and their superiority over the Native People. This along with spiritual pride, jealousy, envy, greed, bad relationships (adultery was rampant – remember the Scarlet Letter) and other sins, caused the Puritans to lack.

Now at this moment, most scholars write that the drought of 1623 was the cause for much of this. While the drought was hard, it was not an excuse for the many un-righteous things the Puritans were doing.

The peace settlement between this first colony of Puritans and the Wampanoag People meant that the Puritans were to have 15 years to establish a firm colony. By 1629 there were no more than 300 Puritans in present day New England in small and isolated communities.

This survival prompted a wave of Puritans that soon established growing settlements north of Plymouth in Boston and Salem. Over the next 10 years the wave of Puritans greatly increased.

Soon the Puritans begin to discuss “…the legal ownership of the land.” At this time Governor John Winthrop declared the “Indians had not subdued the land” and therefore all uncultivated land should be public domain according to English Common Law.

In other words this meant that the land belonged to the King of England. Thus the colonists decided that they did not need to consult with the Natives and that the land was theirs for the taking. As far as they were concerned they only had to inform the representative of the crown and that was the local governor.

To Biblically defend the force taking of the land from the Native People, the Puritans embraced Psalms 2:8 “Ask of me and I shall give thee the heather for thine inheritance and the uttermost parts of the earth for thy possession.” This forced taking of the land included murder.

A company of Puritans led by Miles Standish actively sought out the head of a local chief. They eventually accomplished this gruesome trophy when they beheaded the Native Leader Wituwamat. The head was displayed on a wooded post in the Town Square of Plymouth.


On May 26, 1637 a force of Puritans attacked about 700 Pequot People near the mouth of the Mystic River at Groton, Connecticut.  The Pequots had gathered for their Annual Green Corn Dance.  During the gathering they were surrounded and attacked by the English and the Dutch.  The Natives were ordered from the Gathering Building and as they came forth they were shot down and cut up.  The rest were burned alive in the building.

The English Captain John Mason and Commander John Underhill attacked the camp with the words

“…fire, sword, blunderbuss, and tomahawk….” They also added that “…to see them {Indians} frying in the fire, and the streams of their blood quenching the same and the stench was horrible, but the victory seemed a sweet sacrifice to the great delight to the Pilgrims and they gave praise thereof to God.” The next day, the Governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony declared: “A day of Thanksgiving, thanking God that they had eliminated over 700 men, women and children.”

A second Pequot Village was attacked, massacred and destroyed on June 5, 1637 near present-day Stonington and a third Pequot Village was attacked, massacred and destroyed on July 28, 1637 near present day Fairfield.

A 1925 recreation of Brownscombe's earlier 1914 painting of the First Thanksgiving at Plymouth, significant in that it omits the Plains Indian headdresses that were criticized as non-historically accurate in her 1914 version.

The Puritan fathers believed they were the Chosen People of God and that this justified anything that they did. They were in a sense Calvinists that believed most of humanity was predestined to damnation.

During this period of their history the Puritans along with other European sects declared days of thanksgiving to celebrate mass murder more than to celebrate harvest.  In fact for the next 100 years every “Thanksgiving Day” ordained by any leader (Governor, etc.) was to honor the gruesome “victories” of 1637 and thanking God that the “battles” had been won.

Learning from the Puritans, in 1641 the Dutch began to offer scalp money for Natives. The Dutch Governor Willem Kieft of Manhattan paid money for the scalps of each Native brought to him. In 1643 Governor Kieft ordered the massacre of the Wappinger People.

In this massacre, 80 Native People were killed and their severed heads were kicked around the streets of the village of Manhattan. One Native was castrated, skinned, and then forced to eat his own flesh while many colonist watched and laughed. Later, Kieft got Commander Underhill to carry out a massacre near present day Stamford, Connecticut. A village was set on fire and around 500 Natives were put to the sword.

Soon the settlers launched an all out genocide of the Native People. The government of Massachusetts made an order offering 29 shillings bounty for every Native scalp and 40 shillings for every Native prisoner that could be sold into slavery. Colonial men were allowed to enslave and rape any Native woman and enslave any Native child under what was thought to be the age of 14.

Any Native People that had converted to Christianity were accused of shooting into the trees during battles with the hostiles and were therefore enslaved or killed. Other peaceful Natives of Dartmouth and Dover were invited to a negotiating meeting in which they were taken captive and sold into slavery. Colonial Law gave permission to “…kill savage Indians on sight at will.”

By 1675 Massachusetts and surrounding colonies were in an all out war with the Wampanoag People. The Wampanoag leader Metacomet (called King Phillip by the white man) grew angrier as he watched the steady destruction of his culture and his people. He was forced to strike out with raids on several isolated towns for food.

Captain Benjamin Church tracked down and killed Metacomet. His body was drawn and quartered and the parts as Captain Church said were “…left for the wolves.” Metacomet’s hands were cut off and sent to Boston for display and his head was sent to Plymouth where it was set upon a poke on the newly declared Thanksgiving Day of 1675. Metacomet’s son was to be killed because the Puritans proclaimed that “…the offspring of the Devil must pay for the sins of their father.”

Instead, he was sold to a slave ship bound for the Caribbean.

On June 20, 1676 the Puritans governing council held a meeting to determine of a way to in their own words; “…express thanks for the victories in War with the Heathen Natives….”

And from that moment they proclaimed June 29 as a Day of Thanksgiving.  The celebration over the “heathen Indians” became a major event and was celebrated semi-annually among the New Englanders and the early colonies for many, many years to come.

That proclamation is reproduced here in the same language and spelling as the original:

June 20, 1676:


“The Holy God having by a long and Continual Series of his Afflictive dispensations in and by the present Warr with the Heathen Natives of this land, written and brought to pass bitter things against his own Covenant people in this wilderness, yet so that we evidently discern that in the midst of his judgements he hath remembered mercy, having remembered his Footstool in the day of his sore displeasure against us for our sins, with many singular Intimations of his Fatherly Compassion, and regard; reserving many of our Towns from Desolation Threatened, and attempted by the Enemy, and giving us especially of late with many of our Confederates many signal Advantages against them, without such Disadvantage to ourselves as formerly we have been sensible of, if it be the Lord's mercy that we are not consumed, It certainly bespeaks our positive Thankfulness, when our Enemies are in any measure disappointed or destroyed; and fearing the Lord should take notice under so many Intimations of his returning mercy, we should be found an Insensible people, as not standing before Him with Thanksgiving, as well as lading him with our Complaints in the time of pressing Afflictions:

The Council has thought meet to appoint and set apart the 29th day of this instant June, as a day of Solemn Thanksgiving and praise to God for such his Goodness and Favour, many Particulars of which mercy might be Instanced, but we doubt not those who are sensible of God's Afflictions, have been as diligent to espy him returning to us; and that the Lord may behold us as a People offering Praise and thereby glorifying Him; the Council doth commend it to the Respective Ministers, Elders and people of this Jurisdiction; Solemnly and seriously to keep the same Beseeching that being perswaded by the mercies of God we may all, even this whole people offer up our bodies and soulds as a living and acceptable Service unto God by Jesus Christ.”

By 1704 the massive Holocaust and Genocide of the Native People caused Governor Thomas Dudley to declare a “General Thanksgiving for God’s infinite goodness to extend his favors… In defeating and disappointing… the expeditions of the Enemy Indians against us. And the good Success given us against them, by delivering so many of them into our hands….”

When did Thanksgiving become a National holiday?

Now the holiday that most Americans celebrate has nothing to do with the Puritans or the Native Americans.  The holiday most are acquainted with came about during the American Revolution for Independence when in 1777 things looked bleak for the American “Rebels” against the British Crown.

Photo by Kaboompics .com from Pexels

General George Washington sent out a plea to all that “…supported the cause of Freedom…” for a day of prayer and thanksgiving.  Later as President, Washington Proclaimed a Day of Thanksgiving on October 3, 1789 to be observed by all on November 26, 1789.  Not all the new states agreed and not all observed such a day.

While subsequent Presidents and most Americans did not continue the tradition, it was Washington’s proclamation that spurred and guided the 16th President Abraham Lincoln to make a Proclamation of a National Day of Thanksgiving in 1863.  This was a plea to all Americans to have a day of prayer and thanksgiving during the bleak and trying time of our American Civil War.

Lincoln copied Washington and made the proclamation on the same day of October 3 and for the observation of the holiday to be the same as Washington had for Thursday, November 26.

After this, the holiday was proclaimed by every president since Lincoln and observed on the last Thursday of November.  The date has changed a few times with the most recent change done by Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1939.  At the request of many businesses, Roosevelt moved the Thanksgiving Holiday to the 3rd Thursday of November to make for a longer Christmas shopping season.

This change created a huge public out roar and finally in 1941 Congress made the 4th Thursday of November a legal holiday and our National Day of Thanks.


Should you decide to celebrate this holiday on the fourth Thursday of November, please remember the Native Americans.  Weather you be a teacher or a parent or both be very careful not to “sugar coat” what the Pilgrims did and how they treated the Native Americans, not even to the youngest age.

Please avoid stereotypic Thanksgiving pictures, stories, and programs that depict inaccurate images that are unfair and degrading.  By all means do not have children or adults make “Indian headbands, Indian vests”, do ceremonial war dances or such inappropriate things.  Also do not put on “Pilgrim and Indian” pageants or plays (unless they are historically accurate and tell the story from the true perspectives of Native Americans as well as the European immigrants).


Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum: Springfield, Illinois.

Bradford, William & Edward Winslow. 1622. Mourt’s Relation: A Journal of Pilgrims at Plymouth.  London.

Brandford, William.  1854.  Of Plymouth Plantation.  Written 1630-1654, 1st Published Boston.

Franklin D. Roosevelt Presidential Library and Museum: Hyde Park, New York

Gehring, Charles T., Ed.  1983.  Council Minutes, 1652-1654.  Baltimore: New York Historical Manuscripts Series.

Gehring, Charles T., Ed.  1995.  Council Minutes, 1655-1656.  Syracuse: New Netherland Documents Series.

Gehring, Charles T., Ed.  1977.  Delaware Papers, English Period, 1664-1682. Baltimore: New York Historical Manuscripts Series.

Gehring, Charles T., Ed.  1980. Land Papers, 1630-1664. Baltimore: New York Historical Manuscripts Series.

Gorges, Sir Ferdinando.  1622.  A Brief Relation of the Discovery and Plantation of New England.  London.

Gorges, Sir Ferdinando.  1658.  A Brief Narration of the Originall Undertakings of the Advancement of Plantations Into the Parts of America.  London.

Johnson, William.  1927.  Johnson Papers, Vol. V.  Albany.

Johnson, William.  1957.  Johnson Papers, Vol. XII. Albany.

Pory, John.  1622.  A Description of Plymouth.  London.

Pratt, Phineas.  1662.  A Court Deposition from Plymouth Colony.  London.

Rosier, James.  1605.  A True Relation of the Most Prosperous Voyage Made this Present Year 1605 by Caption George Weymouth.  London.

Smith, Captain John.  1614.  A Description of New England.  London.

Smith, Captain John.  1624.  The Generall Historie of Virginia, New England, and the Summer Isles.  London.

Winslow, Edward.  1624.  Good News from New England.  London.

Native American Heritage Month Giveaway
Bonus Code

Enter Now

Home » Native American Articles » Native American Culture » A More Accurate Historical Thanksgiving -What Are You Celebrating?

About Jamie K Oxendine

Jamie K. Oxendine, of the Lumbee Tribe of North Carolina, is the Native American Liaison and Education Consultant for Ohio University in Athens. Ohio. He is also an adjunct professor at the University of Toledo teaching “Indians of North America” and at Lourdes University teaching “Native American Culture” for the Lifelong Learning Center. A frequent speaker on Native American topics, he serves as the director of the Black Swamp InterTribal Foundation in Ohio. As a recording artist, he was three times been nominated for a NAMMY (Native American Music Award).

TAGGED:    thanksgiving  
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
norbert paul schott

thanks for the truth. at next POWWOW i shall ask grandfather WATANKA for forgiveness how self-righteous whites treated the Native Americans.
bless us O great Spirit with truth

[…] Related Info – A More Accurate Thanksgiving […]

[…] read up on the true history of Thanksgiving and you will see why many Native American families do not celebrate it the same way that […]


My Father was a WWll Veteran. He never spoke about it. He only asked one question. ” How do we change ourselves? “. After reading this article I have to ask that same question. Each of us has to dig deep and take responsibility for our behavior towards each other every moment. If we all have the capacity for great evil we also have the capacity for great good. Its OUR choice! All of LIFE is so very precious. Its OUR choice!


From generation to generation this must be told! We all here live in a different era of time where the truth is the only thing that matters so why should we ALL, no matter the race want our children continue to live in fairy tales that soothe the mind. This country isn’t called the “sleeping giant” for nothing. Those who are the “Gatekeepers of Truth” have a duty to teach it to this generation. Inscribe it in the memory of your children so it is imparted in their hearts. Tell them that they now “know “and it is up to them to guard the truth and impart it to “their” children. Bring back the elders to their rightful place to teach the young. Many still live in ignorance in our day and time but many more are awakening to a new earth and are looking for those with wisdom, those who have guarded and protected Mother Earth, wise in all understanding. Not found in religion but the true source of all that we came from, that source from which our fore-Fathers and Mothers who cared for this land long before it was raped and savaged by ignorant peoples, “know”.

Lisa Martin

I cannot thank you enough for reposting this eye opening article. I am sickened by this and how we as children were taught lies in school and how our country is still perpetuating this disgusting story to try and make the first settlers look like they were good people.


It is a pity they do not teach that at school| Most people are only interested in having good time with family and friends, eating some good food on that day…They do not care about the origin of this holiday.

[…] Read the rest of the story  – A More Accurate Historical Thanksgiving. […]


Because of the Native American side in our family, we were told that what we were taught about Thanksgiving in our history classes in school was not the truth. But we were not told by our elders how disgusting it was. I am sure some of it was left out because of our ages. After reading this article, it breaks my heart how the indigenous people were treated. It was appalling! Especially after the Indian peoples helped the European people learn how to survive. What a pay back. The one interest fact I found was the bounty placed on the scalps of the Indians. I remember of trying to tell people that it wasn’t the Natives who started this practice, but very few people believed me because that is the way it is shown in the movies. The Indians eventually did practice scalping, but it was not something that originated with them. Thank-you for the eye opening account of history.

Pam Casada

Great to finally here the truth May the spirits be with you

Phillip Chase Clark

This is one horrific example of the true nature of history as we know it.
The scariest part is that most people show no real drive to divide fact from fiction; history and the sciences that seek to paint it are simply things to endure in school and promptly be forgotten or mutated into creatures of willfully ignorance and the tragic repetition of the past.
For all Native American descendents reading this, I can not apologize for actions that are not my own in earnest, but I can show reverence for fact…and I vow that I will force feed the facts of this disgusting lie to everyone near me.

Free Email Series: What to Expect at Your First Pow Wow