IF THEY HAVE HAD IT THEY WOULD HAVE USED IT – MAYBE?

By Jamie K Oxendine on October 15, 2012
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • MySpace
  • Google Bookmarks
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • LinkedIn
  • email
  • RSS
  • Print

IF THEY HAVE HAD IT THEY WOULD HAVE USED IT – MAYBE?

Native American Use of Trade Materials

By Jamie K. Oxendine, Lumbee/Creek

Editor, PowWows.com

Director, Black Swamp InterTribal Foundation

PRELUDE

How often has one gotten this question:  “They had that back then?”  Or how about this question: “This material was available to American Indians?”

Unfortunately most that ask the above questions usually get the following answer:  “If they have had it they would have used it!”  But that is not the case.

Just about anyone on the Powwow Trial and the Living History Circuit may get these questions and more proposed to them by both Native and Non-Native people.

If you are strictly a Powwow Trail person and one specifically on the modern Powwow Trail the answer should usually be of the following “No.”  For those on the Living History Circuit and especially those at juried historical events the answer may usually be “Yes” and “Maybe.”

Why this difference in the answer?  Well first and foremost the Native American Culture is far from stagnant and like any culture it has evolved and adapted as it has made both mutual contacts and clashes of contacts with other races and cultures.  Second, as with any culture the Native American Culture was evolving and adapting long before contact with any other non-Native American Culture.

EUROPEAN TRADE

The Native Americans desired many of the European Trade goods such as beads, cloth, blankets, ribbons, knives, kettles, tomahawks, guns, medals and silver. The distribution of such goods varied greatly.

The French for instance allowed Natives to come to the forts, missions and settlements.  The British however designated trade at selected rendezvous.  This may seem confusing since “rendezvous” is a French term.  It was very common for Native American Nations to play both the French and the British against each other when it came to trade.  They did this to obtain more and better trade goods and gifts.  Not to be discriminating, Native Americans also did this with the Spanish, Dutch, German and Russian Trade but in many ways that trade was not as lucrative.

While trade helped the Native American Culture it also was a huge curse to the culture.  Natives found themselves more dependent on Trade Goods and less reliant on old skills.

THE POWWOW TRAIL

The Powwow is rather modern and many new and modern materials have been a part of the Powwow since the early 20th Century.  So the modern Powwow Dancer knows that many of the materials used for their “Dance Regalia” did not exist before the 20th Century.  Part of this is the evolution of the culture in use of materials available but the other is the fault of the forced regression of the Native American Culture by the White Man and especially that of the United States Government in the 19th Century.  From the Removal Period to the Post-Reservation Period most of the outward culture of art, dance, fashion, language, music, and more was stripped from the people and actually made illegal.

The Reservation Period and the Post-Reservation Period brought on the advent of “Intertribalism” as various Native American Nations found themselves “thrown” together.  Almost
automatically they began a sharing of everything from art and music to fashion and even faith.  It was during this time that they had to rely on new materials and very limited materials from the local trading posts on the Reservations or from the local traders allowed to visit and trade on the Reservations or in the Native Community.  Before the forced and almost annihilation of the out-ward beauty of the Native American Culture, the people were very frugal and careful of what items they wanted and chose to use from European Trade and
later American Trade.  But as time went by the reliance on Trade Goods damaged the culture and after the Post-Reservation period being frugal was no longer an option.

It is always fascinating to ponder on how the culture may have evolved in use of materials and skills had there been no forced migrations and removal.

THE LIVING HISTORY CIRCUIT

Now for the Living History Circuit, anything not natural is extremely frowned upon.  Some juried events will even test a strand of one’s clothing with a simple burn test to make sure that only natural materials of cotton, fur, leather, linen, silk and wool are used.   

After European contact, Native Americans greatly valued many items of the new European trade.  But contrary to popular belief they did not desire or use all that the Europeans and later Americans had to offer.  Native Americans were very prudent and most discerning.  They learned very early on the concept of quality versus quantity and the value of fine workmanship.  Over time they became very discriminating.  Rene-Robert de LaSalle noticed as early as the 1670s that the Native Americans were very astute bargainers.   Father Louis Hennepiin who traveled with LaSalle wrote in his journal: “As regards to trade, the Indians are shrewd enough.  They do not allow themselves to be deceived, but they consider everything attentively and study to know the goods.”

BEADS EXAMPLE

Native American Beadwork

To say that Native Americans did not love beads is a critical understatement.  The use of beads for everything from common decoration to prized possessions and even spiritual representations has been an integral manner of the Native American Culture.  Before White contact beads were of course made by hand with great precision that took a massive amount of time and skill.  Beads were made from amber, bone, clay, coral, horn, ivory, metal, obsidian, shell, stone, teeth and wood.

It was no surprise that the Native Americans greatly adored the new beads offered by the Europeans.   These included new beads of glass, ceramic, and cast metal from places like France, Germany, Russia and Venice as well as beads of various materials from Africa, China and India.  The plethora of beads was amazing but even with such a bounty the Natives learned of quality versus quantity almost immediately.   They soon learned that the best beads came from France, India and Venice.

Contrary to popular belief, the Native Americans did not just accept and use any kind of beads.  They were quite selective in both color and style of bead.  Journals of some European and later American Traders indicated that Natives found some beads to be unacceptable as being unpleasant in color, material and style.

SILVER EXAMPLE

Not all Tribes used German Silver because it was there.  As most know it is neither German nor Silver.  It is an alloy of copper, nickel and zinc that became widely available in the early 19th Century.  The name does come from the fact that it was mainly introduced by German metal workers in the 19th Century.  A German Chemist gets credit for perfecting the perfect blend of the 3 alloys.  But becoming widely available and actually being widely used or wanted are very different factors.  This is because not all Native Americans liked German Silver.  It was not extensively used by some Eastern Woodland Tribes as they highly preferred Sterling Silver instead and found German Silver to be less than quality for their taste.

When it came to Trade Silver, the Eastern Woodland Native Americans had learned what superior Trade Silver was since its early introduction in American Trade.  By the time of the French & Indian War the Native People were very perceptive on the value and quality of Trade Silver from the English, French, Dutch and American Silversmiths.  But as with most manufactured goods, German Silver flooded the market for various reasons and quantity alone over took quality.  In other cases, choice was not an option as Sterling Silver was not available even when wanted.  For these reasons German Silver had a wide use with Tribes west of the Great Lakes and Tribes on the Great Plains but a much varied used among some Eastern Woodland Tribes.

DYES EXAMPLE

Although the Europeans brought a eclectic array of dyes in many colors and hues the Native Americans actually upheld their skills of using indigenous dyes obtained from animal parts, dung, bark, berries, buds, earth, flowers, leaves, nuts, roots, seeds, twigs and so forth.

The French alone had over 220 master dyes as early as the 17th Century and along with the English and other Europeans they had many colors to offer the Native Americans.  It is not
sure why the Native Americans still choose to maintain some original dyes but they did gladly accept certain colors from the Europeans right away.  This included the vivid vermillion red and the glowing pure white just to name a couple.

TRADE CLOTH EXAMPLE

The Native Americans did not just take any cloth offered to them.  They learned quickly who had the best wool, cotton, linen, and silk and this was from the English, the French
and the Germans.

The English were preferred for their wool.  The French were preferred for their cotton and silk.  The Germans were preferred for their linen.

Because of this very careful discrimination, the Europeans began to compete for the Natives attention in Trade.  Each European power beefed up their quality and quantity of cloth goods to grab the Native eye and it became a fashion war of who could be the most ostentatious.

Some of the most requested fabrics for shirts were from the French and the English in cotton calico, and cotton chintz with large bright block prints.  The common white shirt with or without ruffles was also popular in cotton muslin and linen.  But if they could get it the Natives heavily preferred the beauty of the rather huge and very vibrant block prints.

In the 18th Century the rage was the following: The French boasted Chinese curved designs and patterns while the English boasted India paisleys and floral designs and patterns.
By the 19th Century the rage was the neo-classical straight lines and small flowers from the French and classical flowers and lines from the English.

Even after the grand establishment of America, the Native Americans were a bit peculiar about American textiles as they still preferred the beauty of the European Mills.

CONCLUSION

Just because they had access to it did not mean they used it as there were astute trading practices of the Native Americans.  Not all items of trade caught their eye for use.  Without going into great detail, we have seen that some beads were not liked, some dyes were not wanted and some cloth was inferior.  These are just a few examples as we know of many more trade objects that were not coveted due to material, color, style and more.

Whatever ones “Native American Clothing” or “Native American Regalia” may be make sure that great patience has been poured into the design and materials of each and every part.  One does not have to be rich or spend excessive amounts of money on materials.   Instead be careful and even prudent as the Native American Ancestors were and also be preserving and make sure that quality beats quantity.

Whether one wants to be modern or historically accurate to a certain time period is a choice, but regardless of what one wants to have always do some research so that when the questions come the education may follow.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Hartman, Sheryl.  2000.  Indian Clothing of the Great Lakes: 1790-1840.  Liberty, UT: Eagles View Publishing.

Hodge, William, H.  1981.  The First Americans: Then and Now.   New York: Holt Rinehart & Winston.

Johnson, Michael, G.  1990.   American Woodland Indians.  Oxford: Osprey.

Johnson, Michael, G.  1995.   American Indians of the Southeast.  London: Reed International.

Johnson, Michael, G.  2003.  Tribes of the Iroquois Confederacy.  Oxford: Osprey.

Johnson, Michael, G.  2006.   Indian Tribes of the New England Frontier.  Oxford: Osprey.

Johnson, Michael, G.  2011.   North American Indian Tribes of the Great Lakes.  Oxford: Osprey.

McKenney, Thomas & Hall, James.  1933.  The Indian Tribes of North America. Edinburgh: John Grant.

Mails, Thomas.  1972.  Mystic Warrios of the Plains.  New York: Doubleday & Company.

Mails, Thomas.  1973.  Dog Soldiers, Bear Men and Buffalo Women.  NJ: Prentice Hall.


TOPICS: Blog, Featured, Native American Articles, Native American Culture, Native American History

Related Posts

17 Responses to “IF THEY HAVE HAD IT THEY WOULD HAVE USED IT – MAYBE?”

  1. Rebecca Hunt Locklear says:

    Very nice! What an education! I learned a ton from this one Jamie. Wow! I had no idea about the beads and cloth. Thanks!!!!

  2. Tammy Kinderman says:

    Great Article! I learned a few things myself. Very well written.

  3. June nix says:

    Great writing Jamie, I always enjoy reading your article. They are informative and I always learn something new.

  4. Tom Iron Eagle says:

    Very nice Bro, learned something I never knew about the trade silver. Thanks bro!

  5. Unagog says:

    Until reading this story, I didn’t know what “German Silver” was. Great Article.

  6. Sue Kuie says:

    Very informative article, thanks for sharing Jamie!

  7. Jason says:

    Im curious about the many of the “facts” presented in this article. Nearly all examples of 18th century silverwork found in a Native context is actually pure silver. Tutanage/German Silver… was not introduced until much later.
    As to the patterns supposedly prefered, there are massive volumes of extant cloth which survive, as well as artwork, and written documents which would disagree with our claims. For a primer on what was really available in the 18th century, check out Florence Montgomery’s “Textiles in America”.

  8. Jamie K Oxendine says:

    And as I mentioned in the paragraphs on Trade Silver, German Silver as we know it was a 19th Century product – but the concept of what would be called German Silver before it was called German Silver did exist in Trade in America before the 19th Century. This metal known as Tutanage or Argentan or Nickel Silver was available in the 18th Century and was of use as a substitute for real silver. As known the German Metalworkers eventfully perfected the formula and thus its name became known as German Silver.

    As for the Trade Cloth yes we know there were massive volumes of cloth. The French alone had hundreds of warehouses full of just Trade Cloth and Trade Shirts for the Native Americans of the North East and Great Lakes as gifts and even bribes to get their “allegiance” so to speak. And that was just the warehouses of Trade Cloth as they had warehouses of other trade materials.

    The patterns preferred are only a small example of what was popular during the time. As said there were massive amounts of cloth and what was and what was not popular can also be subjective to the “fashion” of the day. A perfect example: 100 years from now even with the incredible documentation we have, there could still be a huge discussion on whether stripes or solids were the fashion of the day in 2013.

  9. Laura says:

    Wonderfully informative, Jamie! I’m glad to be learning from you before I get any farther along in my regalia.

  10. Frank ( Tommy ) Elliott says:

    Not to get off topic, but Becky & I really enjoyed ourselves at Ft. Ancient last week. It wa good to see you and am looking forward to seeing you again next year or later this year in Perrysburg.

  11. Lee Slusher says:

    It is great to see that the idea of Native Americans just taking whatever they could get from the Europeans is false.

  12. NoahYork says:

    I love how some people think that if a people live without certain goods and materials, they are too primitive to grasp ideas like quality versus quantity, or any of the other misperceptions of Native Americans. Certain cultures may have some advancements that others lacked, but the intelligence of man is universal.

  13. Alvelia Farmer says:

    Very informative and detailed. It does make me wonder what would Native American culture had been like if it wasn’t removed…

  14. Mark Chase says:

    I never knew the trading history of Native America was so complex! I found it especially interesting that the tribes so carefully distinguished the different types of silver from one another and only used what was thought to have the most value.

  15. Douglas Spirit Bear Neely says:

    Well it just proves the old adage about learning something new everyday. I always thought that German Silver was just a lesser grade of silver! Good article!!

  16. Nate Zona says:

    This is great! A wonderful source of information, which helps to clear up some misconceptions. Thank you for writing it!

  17. Gary Jeffrey III says:

    Like others stated above, I was completely unaware that there were so many hurdles to overcome in regards to trading for a lot of the Natives. Yet again another story to serve as an eye-opener for those who were here in North America before all of the settlers came crashing in.

Leave a Comment








    

Pow Wow Calendar Search

 
Month: Year:
Location:
Help support PowWows.com

New Threads

Dance Styles

Straight Dancing

Straight Dancing

The Straight Dance from Oklahoma Native American Tribes is a formal, tailored, prestigious form of southern dance clothes.   The overall effect is of reassuring solidity, with everything closely matched and …

Crafts

MakingRegaliaLeatherBelt

Making Regalia – How to Construct Leather Belts – Craft Tutorial

Host Juaquin Lonelodge is back for Season 2 of Making Regalia. In the first episode he shows us how to construct leather belts, which he says an absolute regalia necessity. …

AMERICAN INDIAN PHOTO GALLERIES

View thousands of photos of dancing, singing, crafts and more. Share your photos online!